I have this horrible habit of giving up on bands after a couple records for no good reason. I don’t know if it’s a short attention span on my part, a desire to find something a bit more hip or what, but I end up missing out on a lot of good bands as they mature and change. Thankfully, over the past year thanks for the wonder of emusic.com, I’ve been able to go back and rediscover many of these bands. Emusic offers a legitimate download service that allows you to download songs and albums in a cheap and convenient fashion.
A while back, Emusic expanded their offerings quite a bit and added a lot of classic indie rock. I found myself downloading and enjoying many things I wouldn’t even think of looking for in a record store. So a few months back, I came across a Teenage Fanclub compilation called Four Thousand Seven Hundred and Sixty Seconds: A Short Cut To Teenage Fanclub. I was excited to see their name and a nostalgic feeling came up as I downloaded the album.
In many ways, Teenage Fanclub was my gateway to the world of indie rock. I had been a huge music fan for years but never really associated myself with any particular movement. All of the music movements of the 80’s from New Romantic to Mod to Goth all seemed so insular and based upon fashion. I was never drawn to music as a fashion statement. Sometime in 1990, I picked up the first Teenage Fanclub album, A Catholic Education. Somehow buying that album made me start looking into other bands on Matador Records. Similarly, buying a single from Superchunk turned me on to early releases on Merge Records. Here I began to discover a muisical movement based upon a do it yourself ethic from the bands and a label culture that was just based on putting out music that was good regardless of genre. Look at Matador Records back then. There couldn’t have been bands more different than H.P. Zinker and Teenage Fanclub but Gerard Cosloy was putting them out for seemingly no other reason than that he liked them. That was an inspiring and empowering idea and shaped my future in the music world for the next few years.
Getting back to Teenage Fanclub, I bought that first album, put it on my turntable and was awestruck. I hadn’t really been moved so much by a pop record since REM’s Chronic Town. Here was a band that was just masterful at writing catchy songs and also played them in an unpretentious, underproduced fashion. The result was a record that really connected on many levels. I envisioned a bunch of innocent Scottish kids who had listened to a lot of Big Star and Beatles records but were just doing their own thing with little regard to what was popular at the time.
Over time I heard rumblings that they were signing to a major label. That burst my bubble a bit as I still had this idealistic picture of bands doing their thing just for the music. Major labels were evil in the now insular indie rock world and no one (with the possible exception of Sonic Youth) on a major label could be trusted. So, risking my indie rock credibility, I ran out and purchased their second full length, Bandwagonesque. The joy I felt upon listening to that CD for the first time cannot even be described. Bandwagonesque was the perfect hybrid of the rough but charming indie rock of A Catholic Education combined with the big, lush pop sound of the first two Big Star records. That CD was in constant rotation on my stereo and their live show on that tour was one of my favorite shows of that era.
Soon after that, I started reading more about the band and discovered that they had left Matador Records on very bad terms. They had signed for a two record deal but began negotiating with Geffen before delivering a second album to Matador. After signing, they delivered the wonderful Bandwagonesque to Geffen and left Matador with a pretty atrocious set of studio out-takes and covers on The King. Matador declined to even out out this record and the days of Teenage Fanclub as an indie band were over. I took this stuff really seriously and for the most part turned my back on the band. After all, there were thousands of indie bands doing things for the right reasons. I was going to spend my money where it mattered.
Coming back to the recent past, thanks to Emusic, I came across this Teenage Fanclub compilation and downloaded it on a whim. Instantly I remembered why I liked this band so much. While it contained a few tracks from those two albums I loved, it contained a lot more tracks from subsequent Geffen albums and records that were released after Geffen dropped them. They were still making those classic pop songs but seemed to be finding their own way more and more. The need to sound like Big Star seemed to have passed them by and they were experimenting with more complex arrangements. Even with these more mature arrangelemts, they never lost the hooks and earnestness that attracted me to them in the first place.
A few months after downloading this compilation, I read that the band would actually be touring the United States. This was a real shock as I assumed that they had disbanded long ago. Even tough they weren’t playing near me in Boston, I decided that this occasion was worthy of a road trip and I quickly bought tickets and planned a trip to New York. This seemed a reasonble pigrammage since this was a band that had changed my way of thinking 14 years ago.
To top things off, Teenage Fanclub just released a new album, Man-Made this year. I anxiously downloaded it to see if any of that magic was left after so many years. This is a much more understated record than the ones that initially hooked me but after a few listens, I begin to appreciate the more nuanced approach. They still have that basic ability to create great hooky pop songs but they don’t don’t hit you over the head the way the earlier recordings did. The songs grow in a slower and more natural way - probably a natral progression as the band members have grown up. Man_made is a fine record and I’m looking forward to seeing how the live band has aged in the last decade. I’ll be seeing them this Saturday in New York and will likely be giving a report here sometime next week.
Here are some resources if you want to catch up on this band.
Teenage Fanclub Homepage
Buy Teenage Fanclub music at insound.com